Key takeaways
- Electrospray (ESI) tends to give several charge states of the same peptide; MALDI mostly gives one. Both are read as mass-to-charge (m/z).
- Expected mass comes in two kinds: monoisotopic (high-resolution instruments) and average (lower resolution, and most labels). Check which one a report uses.
- Agreement is judged against a tolerance, in daltons or parts per million, that the lab should state.
- LC-MS separates first and then weighs each peak, which catches impurities a single spectrum would blur together.
- Same mass does not mean same molecule: scrambled sequences, leucine versus isoleucine, and D- versus L-amino acids weigh the same.
01How a mass spectrometer weighs a peptide
A mass spectrometer can only move and measure molecules that carry an electric charge. Peptides are fragile, so they need a gentle way to become charged ions without breaking apart.
Two such "soft" methods made peptide and protein mass spectrometry routine. The 2002 Nobel Prize in Chemistry recognised this work, with shares to John Fenn for electrospray and to Koichi Tanaka for soft laser desorption, a laser method closely related to MALDI.
Electrospray (ESI)
The peptide solution is sprayed through a charged needle into a fine mist. As droplets shrink, ions are released carrying one or more extra protons. Described for large biomolecules by Fenn and colleagues in 1989.
MALDI
The peptide is dried onto a plate with a light-absorbing matrix and hit with a laser pulse. Ions are mostly singly charged. Described for proteins by Karas and Hillenkamp in 1988.
The analyser
Separates ions by mass-to-charge ratio (m/z). Time-of-flight, quadrupole and Orbitrap analysers differ mainly in resolution and mass accuracy.
02Observed versus expected mass
The expected mass is calculated from the molecular formula. There are two ways to do it, and reports mix them up.
- Monoisotopic mass uses the most common isotope of each element. It is the first peak in the cluster a high-resolution instrument resolves.
- Average mass weights every isotope by its natural abundance. It is the molecular weight printed on labels, and what a lower-resolution instrument reports when it cannot separate the isotope peaks.
Because a small share of carbon atoms are the heavier carbon-13, each peptide shows a cluster of peaks. For an ion carrying one charge the peaks sit about 1 unit apart; for two charges, 0.5 apart; for three, about 0.33. The spacing tells the analyst the charge.
Illustration: BPC-157, C62H98N16O22 | Value |
|---|---|
| Average molecular weight (as stated by FDA) | 1419.5 |
| Monoisotopic neutral mass | 1418.70 |
| [M+H]+, one charge | m/z 1419.71 |
| [M+2H]2+, two charges | m/z 710.36 |
| [M+3H]3+, three charges | m/z 473.91 |
Calculated by us from the molecular formula in FDA's July 2026 briefing document, as an illustration of the arithmetic. Not a test result.
03Charge states and tolerance
Electrospray usually produces several charge states of one peptide at once, so the same molecule appears at more than one m/z. Software converts them back to a single neutral mass: mass = z × (m/z) − z × 1.00728, where z is the charge and 1.00728 is the mass of a proton.
The match is then judged against a tolerance. Accurate-mass work expresses the error in parts per million (ppm): the difference between measured and calculated mass, divided by the calculated mass, times one million. As arithmetic, 5 ppm of 1,419.71 is about 0.007. A lower-resolution instrument works in tenths of a dalton or whole daltons instead.
- The report says which mass (monoisotopic or average) it compared, the ion or charge state used, and the tolerance.
- "Identity: conforms" with no observed mass, no expected mass and no tolerance cannot be checked.
04Why LC-MS beats MS alone
A sample sprayed or spotted straight into the instrument gives one combined spectrum. Every molecule that ionised is in it at once, and abundant components can suppress weaker ones.
LC-MS puts an HPLC column in front of the mass spectrometer. Molecules leave the column one after another and are weighed as they arrive, so each chromatographic peak gets its own mass. The UV trace and the mass trace can be read together. In a 2018 Waters application note, impurities eluting under the main peptide peak at the same time were found only by pulling their masses out of the MS data.
The validation guideline ICH Q2(R2) recognises this pairing: where one procedure cannot discriminate enough, two or more should be combined, and isotope resolution in mass spectrometry is given as an example of specificity built into a technology.
05Reading an identity result, step by step
Check the sequence and formula match the label, and whether the figure is monoisotopic or average.
Note each m/z and its charge state. Several charge states agreeing is stronger than one.
Turn m/z into neutral mass and compare like with like, within the stated tolerance.
As arithmetic: about +16 per added oxygen (oxidation), about +22 for a sodium adduct in place of a proton, and the mass of one residue missing for a deletion sequence.
Identity and HPLC purity for the same lot, ideally from the same LC-MS run.
06What mass spectrometry can't tell you
| Question | Why MS alone falls short | What helps |
|---|---|---|
| How much peptide is in the vial? | Signal depends on how well each molecule ionises, not only on how much is there | Quantitative HPLC against a reference standard; net peptide content |
| How pure is it? | A spectrum shows what ionised; impurities that ionise poorly can be missed | HPLC area-% purity, ideally as LC-MS |
| Is the sequence in the right order? | A scrambled sequence has the same mass | Tandem MS (MS/MS), which breaks the peptide into b and y fragments that read the order |
| Leucine or isoleucine? | Same formula, same mass; standard MS/MS does not separate them | Specialised fragmentation or other methods |
| D- or L-amino acids? | Mirror-image forms weigh the same; racemisation during synthesis creates such impurities | Chiral chromatography or chiral amino-acid analysis |
| Endotoxin, sterility, water, counter-ions? | Outside what an identity test measures | Endotoxin and sterility tests, water and counter-ion assays |
An identity match also says nothing about whether a substance is safe or effective in people. It answers one question: is this the molecule the label names.
Plain-English summary of analytical chemistry sources and regulator documents, checked 17 November 2026. Not legal or medical advice.